Looking in the mirror isn’t always easy. Imagine if that mirror is your twin.

After years of mulling it over, the 62-year-old identical twins underwent lower face and neck lifts at Bryn Mawr Hospital this past September. Because each procedure takes four hours, Dr. Jason Bloom usually does only one per day. But he agreed to the sisters’ request to have the surgeries on the same day. “It didn’t matter to me who went first,” Bloom says with a laugh. “I let the sisters figure it out.”

Five weeks after their surgeries, the women have agreed to meet at Jane’s Berwyn home to talk about their experiences. They’ve healed well—neither has obvious bruises, and the bandages are gone. They look great (though neither wants her real name used).